Public Relations Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes
July 19, 2007, 10:00 am - 3:00 pm
Millbury Public Library
Committee Members
Present: Melissa Campbell, Janet Eckert, Susan Flannery, David Gray, Vicki Kaufman, Em Claire Knowles, Kathy Lowe, Rob Maier, Pat McLeod, Anna Popp, Charlotte Rabbitt, Dawn Thistle
Absent: Libby Fox, Deborah Lang Froggatt, Greg Pronevitz, Emily Salaun, Stephanie St. Laurence
Others Present: Jill Kushner, Lee Surette and Steve Swets, Buyer Advertising
Proceedings
Meeting called to order at 10:00 am
David Gray, MBLC Director of Communications & Public Information, welcomed new members and representatives of Buyer Advertising, the MBLC's new agency of record hired to implement its three-year marketing plan.
Timeline
Steve Swets presented a suggested timeline for the rest of 2007 that addressed Creative & Media, 20-Somethings, Marketing Support and Web Portal. David Gray said that some of the projects had shifted a bit in the first year of the Three-Year Marketing Plan due to the need to develop the Web Portal and Focus Group funding which could be done earlier that originally planned.
RFQ Review
Steve Swets went over the RFQ that Buyer Advertising had presented to the MBLC to insure that the members of the Committee understood it, as well as commented on it. The discussion that followed is synthesized below.
- Will we cover current library users in the focus groups? (suggesting no)
- Media thoughts
- Prior partnership with Univision was fruitful
- Non-media support provided
- Explore opportunities when the time comes - Radio One and WILD would be stations to look for the AA audience
- Gates Foundation -
- Spanish language outreach support
- Workshops and training
- Might there be funding available if we approach them about our program
- Translation
- How many languages
- Consider: Spanish, Russian, Brazilian, Portuguese, Haitian Creole
Objectives
#1 Increase library usage
- A healthy discussion of existing activity measurement took place
- ARIS offers some possibilities
- Metrics for 2007 may serve as base numbers
- Other possibilities include:
- New library cards issued
- Web site hits (total activity vs. unique visitors an issue)
- Attendance is not often consistent or accurately measured
- School libraries are interested in parents awareness, value of, and interest in, professional staffing
- Giving your kids a head start is a strong message for parents
#2 Promote the technology resources available
- Part of supporting a 21st century image
- The "Partnership for 21st century skills" may provide some insight/support
- Libraries have hidden online gems/resources (The NYT database)
- Consideration for the "safety factor" for parents
- Downloadable resources are big
- Need to differentiate what's available on Google and from the library
- Message can be "scaled" to avoid scaring technology neophytes
- "Access" may be the big concept here
#3 Introduce a 21st century image of Massachusetts libraries
- E-resources
- 50% of libraries have remodeled or rebuilt - capturing the architectural image of the new library is important to breaking stereotypes even though not all libraries are new
- Male librarians are part of the updated image
- Hip, cool - an emotional component is important
#4 Create excitement among target audiences
- Word association suggestions included:
- Interactive, pop culture, wi fi, human, engaging, fun
- Safe, relevant, boundary-less, inclusive, now, world wide
- Comfortable, independent, friendly, customize, current
Suggestions/Thoughts
- Use market research to drive creative - input from non-users will help drive successful communications
- Communicate the "value-added" proposition
- Get people in the store - portal, bricks and mortar, etc.
- Secondary messages can be communicated when they arrive
- The role of the portal will probably be greater with 20 Somethings
- "You get more than your local library" is a strong message
- 20% of circulation involves users from neighboring towns
- Libraries are a gateway to a world of knowledge
- Equity of access to all commonwealth residents is a MBLC goal
- "More than books" is still a valuable message
- This is not "one size fits all"
- "Create your own library"
- Should the tag line deliver a concrete message
Creative
General thoughts
- Agency discussed the fact that while concepts are static with one photo/person the executions (particularly on television) will feature multiple units of people with diversity on many fronts (gender, ethnicity, age of children, etc)
- Agency reiterated its belief that reaching non-users effectively will take an intrusive message - broadcast more so than newspaper - but that print/printed materials could play a valuable support role
- All agree that eventual executions should:
- Show people in libraries
- Contain a balance of books and tv/video-like footage
- Icons have a possible role
- Explore this further
- Use the International symbol
| Concept | Slips | Stars | Ave |
|---|---|---|---|
|
"At the Library, there's something for everyone." (list ad) |
6 |
16 |
2.66 |
|
"Give your kids the world" (mom/daughter with magic card strip) |
6 |
11 |
1.83 |
|
"Meet Kara, one of our search engines" |
5 |
11 |
2.20 |
|
"Rediscover…From the world wide web to Charlotte's Web…" |
5 |
8 |
1.60 |
|
"Shelve your old ideas (young man with headphones) |
5 |
8 |
1.60 |
|
"Start at the library, see where " (young woman with magic card strip) |
3 |
8 |
2.66 |
Individual concept comments
"At the Library, there's something for everyone." (mother son with lists)
- Something for everyone
- An appealing concept
- It's all about different people finding something at a library
- "reminds me of bookmarking my favorite web sites"
- Could be offered as a local promotion
- Could take pictures of patrons and make posters
- Libraries have software that could support this (need more information)
- Can provide input for local libraries - form of market research
- Opportunity for celebrity participation
- Someone like Big Papi and child would be a huge success
"Give your kids the world. Take them to the library." (mother and daughter)
- Lots of warmth - they're happy
- Headline is very strong (multiple mentions)
- Communicates the overall message that parents who bring their kids to the library do well by them
- Eventual execution (if selected) would show them doing something library-like
- Card needs to presented in a way that makes sense
- Not a purchase
- Not a specific library card
- Swipe card at the library and go…..
- They are doing a good thing
"Meet Kara…"
- Execution in a library with someone who is obviously a librarian will eliminate the issue of whether Kara is a librarian or a customer (Kara is her own search engine)
- Headline is a strong message (multiple comments)
- Could be a bit less serious for 20 Somethings - they like some irreverence
- Could this be an execution that local libraries customize for their use?
- Has broad appeal - uses humor and unexpected art well (multiple comments)
- Charlottes Web is a classic
- Still popular today
- 20 Somethings will have grown up with it
- The headline is a strong element (multiple comments)
- communicates a valuable message
- "Rediscover" is a strong concept
- The "From To" concept is good - a play on words/has legs
- Artwork (laptop) helps by picturing it as other than a book
-
"Rediscover your library. From the World wide web to Charlotte's Web, there's something here for every one."
"More than books…" (Young man on headphones)
- Nicely human with some coolness
- Use of a male is good
- Headline is nice play on words
- "Shelve your old…" is a strong line but would be more effective if it was balanced by artwork that affirms the "new ideas" we want to you to walk away with
- Perhaps the person is shown in an office or at home
- The young woman looks confident and independent
- The card drew me in (see earlier card comments)
- "Is this last year's idea"
- URL visibility is important (time on screen and size)
- Scene suggestions
- Old master to new - could old master be something very strong like the shark biting the ship painting
- Could the new master be something like anime (graphic novels)
- At beginning show people entering a library
- Have a stronger "book" presence - seems to over emphasize TV/video (i.e., Harry Potter book cover vs. movie clip)
- Strong sense of imagination
- Could dinosaur be from a pop-up book that morphs into a real dinosaur
- The URL should last us a long time - beyond the projected three years of this campaign
- There may be four categories of successful URLs
- Catchy
- Informative
- Commonsense
- Library attributes
- "Beyond books.org" should be a candidate
- Libraries (plural) should be considered to evidence the vast nature of the access you get
- Is a state tie-in important (i.e., MA, Mass)
- "Network" is another potential attribute
- "ReadsinMA.org" will be linked to the portal
- Should be hip/cool - attention getting and memorable
- Buy ".com" version of the URL as well for protection and link to ".org"
- The ALA has ilovelibraries.org
-
"Start at the library. See where you end up." (20 Something woman)
TV Spot
URL
The URL needs to be identified fairly soon - no later than the August meeting
The agency will use the input from the offsite to develop URL choices
Observations
Next Meetings:
- Wednesday, August 15, 2007, 10 am - 1 pm
- Leominster Public Library, 30 West Street, Leominster
- Wednesday, October 3, 2007, 10 am - 3 pm
- Needham Free Public Library, 1139 Highland Street, Needham
